Though I didn't listen to nearly as many albums this year as I do normally, I still managed to find a number of impressive works by various groups, many of which I'd never heard before. I don't know enough about music and musical trends to break down the musical landscape of the year in the way I do film, but here at least are my picks for the finest albums of the year, a selection of rap, pop and rock tunes that dug into the recesses of my mind in the most maddening ways.
1. Kanye West — My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy
With rock stars now divided between the introspective or, in the case of such megastars as Bono, the preaching, Kanye West's My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy is a refreshing bit of self-congratulation from the best egomaniac in pop music today. Mixing the earnestness of his previous album with the whirlwind of self-mythologizing bravado from his early stuff, Yeezy makes not only his best album but a masterpiece of mainstream hip-hop, a genre that's been hard up for truly great records over the last few years. Not a single song fails, and several could vie for the title of best Kanye song, from the King Crimson-quoting deification of "Power" to the guest star smorgasbord of "Monster" to the simultaneously plaintive and bitingly satiric "Runaway." I've always liked Kanye's braggadocio more than his music -- even though I've enjoyed that too -- but this is a modern classic.
Personal blog of freelance critic Jake Cole, with exclusive content and links to writing around the Web.
Friday, December 24, 2010
Thursday, December 23, 2010
Black Swan
For a time, I fretted Black Swan would reduce its protagonist to a reductive set of sexual clichés, the virginal naïf whose madness could be cured by one good lay. As someone who has grown up with various anxieties, I've always found the phrase "Loosen up" to border on the offensive, displaying an utter lack of understanding on the part of people who are surely well-meaning but also condescending and oversimplifying. As the entire arc of the prima ballerina in Darren Aronofsky warped thriller is founded on the need for her to lose control a bit, I braced myself for a childish, possibly sexist mixture of Roman Polanski's Repulsion and Michael Powell's The Red Shoes.Instead, I got an inventive, and brutally raw blend of Aronofsky's well-established visual acuity with his budding affinity for piercing character drama. Nassim Nicholas Taleb developed an idea he termed the "black swan theory," in which an event happens that surprises everyone -- such as the discovery of black swans in the 18th century after the term had become an idiomatic expression for that which could not exist -- and people rationalize the aberration in retrospect into a shift that could have been anticipated. Black Swan itself amusingly fits into this theory, helping to explain how the maker of visual feasts with thin characterizations could suddenly leap from a film as philosophical and detached as The Fountain to one of the most perfectly executed character tragedies of the last decade.
Opening in the dreams of the aforementioned dancer, Nina (Natalie Portman), Black Swan instantly announces its blend of hand-held, grainy footage with a subjective and fanciful mise-en-scène. Nina dances against infinite black, her white tutu and pale skin glowing in the abyss as a pale spotlight illuminates only her. Dancing Tchaikovsky's Swan Lake in her head, the dream ends with the Swan Queen dancing with the evil Von Rothbert, foreshadowing the central conflict of the film to come, one that does not particularly involve an antagonist but revolves around this tango between ingénue and villain.
Nina awakes and heads to practice, where she guns for the role she danced in her sleep. Using fleet glances and mild but unmistakable passive-aggression, Aronofsky displays the competitive spirit of the dancers, exacerbated by emaciation and overwork. In the dressing room, the dancers mock Beth (Winona Ryder), the prima ballerina being edged out for her age, and the only cliques that seem to form among the individuals competing always seem to be in opposition to Nina. In the studio, some of their antagonism becomes clear: Nina is flawless, dedicated entirely to her craft at the expense of talking to the others for any extended time. So immaculate is her dancing that the theater director, Thomas Leroy (Vincent Cassel), considers not giving her the role of the Swan Queen because while her fragility and composure makes her perfect for the innocent White Swan, she would be all wrong for the looser and more seductive Black Swan-half of the character.
Still, he selects Nina for the part and sets about training her to, in effect, mar her perfection. It's an odd notion, to improve the finest dancer by introducing impurity, and Nina has difficulties with the lesson, to say the least. Raised by a former ballerina (Barbara Hershey) whose own career ended when she got pregnant, Nina has worked her entire life toward proving herself not only among her peers but to the demanding mother that lives vicariously through her.
Thomas wants Nina to seduce the audience, and him, as the Black Swan, and Cassel pours all his leering, rakish sleaze into the role. Leroy is a womanizer, but as much as he loves toying with his stars, his sexual harassment of Nina might also be a ploy to shake her loose. Unfortunately for Nina and everyone else in her life, Thomas tears out the wrong screws, sending Nina deeper and deeper into madness from the stress.
If The Wrestler displayed the travails and heartbreaks of a professional past his prime, Black Swan demonstrates the equal difficulty of the young performer breaking into the spotlight. Randy's escape from reality occurred in the ring, but even then all he could do was bathe in the crowd's love. Unable to loosen up, Nina moves backward into further isolation, and her reality begins to shift and rupture. At the start, she notices a mild rash on her back, and as her efforts to become the Black Swan strain her further, her body reacts in more noticeable ways.
The ease with which Aronofsky recalls the body horror of early David Cronenberg makes the minuscule aberrations in Nina's flesh all the more unsettling. Whether actually splitting a toenail or hallucinating peeling off a strip of skin on her finger, Nina's failing body naturally replicates her crumbling mind, a literal embodiment of the reflective imagery that runs through the film**. Aronofsky suggests as much through mirror images (and the occasional manipulation of same) as he does through the subjective moments: often, we see a character first in a reflection, then in person. Even the characters seem to pick up on this, and they attribute a certain power to mirrors, especially when Nina equates stardom with the private mirror Beth enjoyed as the prima ballerina.
Other touches only compound the mounting insanity. The sound mix isolates the teasing whispers of Nina's peers, especially Veronica (Ksenia Solo, whose eyes look as if they were carved from ice), whose jabs are faint but crystal clear. Then, of course, there's Lily (Mila Kunis), the less talented but more passionate dancer who embodies the Black Swan as much as Nina does the White. The more Nina sinks into her madness, the more Lily filters into as the key to her deliverance but also her downfall. Much has been said about the sex scene between Portman and Kunis, but typically not for how disturbing it is in its outright eroticism. It doesn't make lesbianism horrific, mind you; the sex, as one might expect from two women, is so emotionally complex that its implications seep into the brain until one almost forgets that two gorgeous women are going at it. Almost.
This all feeds into the film's central flaw, that these fractals of tattered sanity do not add up to the same level of character insight that defined Aronofsky's previous film. The director does not particularly care for the nuance of Nina's life, defining her against Lily's forthright sexuality, Thomas' predatory mixture of lasciviousness and "hands-on" artistic molding, Beth's cracked mirror view into her own future and the mother's psychological torture. Even her bulimia seems the product more of her constant stress than a sexist purge of calories to maintain weight. Aronofsky also spares no critical eye for ballet in the same way he dug into the behind-the-scenes grit of wrestling, ignoring the deeper sexual implications of an art that depends entirely on contortion and control of every muscle (though he does at least skirt the issue with his clear looks at undulating back muscles and rigid legs during the dancers' practice)*.
By the same token, Black Swan isn't meant to be a character study nor a feminist text. It's a horror film, one that uses its Super-16 cinematography and thick grain to, yes, add a more realistic vibe to the film's aesthetic, but the grain has a double edge, also separating the audience from full involvement with its hazy sheen. It's tactile yet abstract, like Nina's characterization, and it has the effect of complicating the scares by further blurring the line between objective terror and Nina's subjective reaction to it. If Aronofsky does not plumb the same depths of tortured femininity as Polanski did with Repulsion, he at least presents a masterful evocation of the life-destroying obsession with success. It's almost political: Nina has to make her mark before she gets out of her mid-20s or she'll never make it, while the average person has to commit just as completely now just to maintain a job. Unlike Randy, and like Moira Shearer's Vicky in The Red Shoes, Nina does not want the fame; notoriety is simply the yardstick by which she can measure her mastery. Place Black Swan next to The Social Network as a look at the way professionalism and sexual repression blend in the modern world.
That Aronofsky should have chosen Portman to portray this perfection-hungry ballerina may be the touch that elevates Black Swan to near-greatness. I have long been fascinated with the actress, who always comes off as incredibly approachable -- she did, after all, just launch a production company designed to make stoner comedies for women -- but also has such an other-worldliness to her because of her beauty and intelligence that I have difficulty processing whatever character she plays in a movie because I see Natalie Portman, not Evey Hammond or that Manic Pixie Dream Girl in Garden State. Though her performance does not fully intertwine her life with her character's in the way Mickey Rourke's did, Portman at last breaks through with her finest role since Leon and Beautiful Girls by playing directly into her greatest setback. Cassel's character voices the key issue with Portman's work. The more she loses control to get Nina to the ideal performance, the more Portman finally disappears into the part in a way she hasn't done in more than 10 years. It's a critical breakthrough for the actress, and one that reminds me why I was so bowled over by her teenage performances when I discovered her early work back in my own teens.
To be sure, Black Swan can be manipulative, with its jump scares and constantly building dread that leads into one of the most draining climaxes in recent memory (an appropriate touch for a movie about a virginal protagonist, considering that the first climax is always the most bewildering). But this is not the same director who made the shameless Requiem for a Dream. Aronofsky may be returning to the same area as that movie, but Black Swan is too sly to get caught in that trap again. He's grown too much: would the Requiem-era Aronofsky have ever thought to include a moment as ice-breaking and fantastically funny as a vision of the creature that haunts Nina walking by her with a casual "Hey"? Armed with a terrific score by Clint Mansell that incorporates and refashions Tchaikovsky's Swan Lake score, Aronofsky has made a film that may, ultimately, not have much to say but speaks with such eloquence that we are held rapturous in its power. Nina spends the whole film trying to find the balance between flawed and immaculate. Aronofsky finds it from the start.

*In fact, Aronofsky's best commentary on ballet involves the occasional cuts in the soundtrack, leaving the ballerinas to dance in silence, obliterating the grace of movement with the garish, plodding sight and sound of thudding feet. Suddenly, the art of dance is broken, and we're left wondering why someone would torture herself for so hollow a profession.
**Perhaps the most disturbing of warped reflections is the collage of terrifying, abstract portraits of Nina her mother paints, half of them angelic, half demonic. It's not only indicative of the forces swelling inside the young woman but of the way the mother views her daughter, the light of her life but also the killer of her dreams.
Animal Kingdom
If the emotional range of crime family films stretches from the operatic types of The Godfather to the viscerally felt human beings of GoodFellas, Animal Kingdom strives to find the middle ground between the two. That's not an entirely fair assessment, I grant you, as David Michôd's film cares less for the crime than the characters, but then the same was true of those landmark entries in the genre as well. Unfortunately, if a medium between the conflicting styles exists -- unlikely, considering the mutually annihilating contradictions -- Michôd doesn't find it, and Animal Kingdom slogs along for two hours unable to find a clear direction.It opens strikingly enough, as a zoned-out teenager, Joshua or "J" (James Frecheville) sits watching TV next to a passed-out woman. Only when paramedics arrive do we realize that she has overdosed on heroin, and subsequent detail reveals the woman was the lad's mother. It is a perfectly paced procession, culminating in the dead-eyed teen's transferal to the family his mother tried to protect him from for years. That a heroin addict would find her relatives too horrible for her child suggests something about what kind of people they are, but what choice does J have?
In retrospect, I can see the immediate downturn in the film from this measured opening in its credits sequence, filled with somber, dull sweeps over an engraved plate and still from bank surveillance footage as robbers hold them up. The Codys are a family of robbers and dealers, but Michôd never actually shows that side of the action. It's a perfectly valid artistic decision, of course, but when I reflected on the film, I found it amusing that the director teased the audience with a heist movie even as he honestly conveyed what the film would give the audience: organized crime filmed tediously.
As J gets used to living with his grandmother, he introduces us to the family (via a voiceover narration that is subsequently dropped from the film, which would be cause for snarky complaint were it not such a relief not to hear Frecheville's droning voice overlapping the soundtrack). The oldest son, Andrew a.k.a. Pope (Ben Mendelsohn), stays out of the picture at the beginning, busy planning his various crimes and hiding out from the police. At the Cody home are the middle child, Craig (Sullivan Stapleton), a unstable man who is willing to spend hours tailing a driver who flips him off just to terrify him; Darren (Luke Ford), the youngest son with only a few years on J; and Barry, a family friend who assists Pope in robberies and seems a fourth son at times. And presiding over them all is Janine (Jacki Weaver), a kindly matriarch whose loving attitude toward her children borders on incestuous. She does not say much for most of the film, but Weaver projects a cold authority behind her warmth. Where the matriarch in crime films is always aware of the actions of the men in her life but is ultimately removed from the action, she all but coordinates her children without outwardly doing so.
The first half hour moves swiftly, but apart from the initial introductions, Animal Kingdom makes no headway with its characters. Frecheville has clearly been instructed to play J as an emotionally stunted, blank teenager, but he makes for a poor cipher, and the story bounces off him like radar waves on a stealth bomber. We know to be horrified by his living conditions because the things that happen around him are despicable, but Frecheville is trapped by the role and cannot react to anything.
Every time this film starts to turn around and become something engaging -- particularly when police corruption factors into the hunt for the Cody family -- it stops just as quickly as it started. The cops close in at the half-hour mark and show a disturbing willingness to circumvent the right to a fair trial (to say the least), but the briefest of reprisals appears to back them off for another hour of screen time. Michôd seems to be trying to avoid falling into the unintentional romanticizing and cliché of the crime film, maintaining focus solely on the family and not their exploits or, unless one of the Codys is present, the police procedural work and corruption in the justice system. But no one fills the gaps left by these omissions, and I found myself wishing for a cliché just so I'd have something to hold onto. The mere absence of the usual does not automatically equate to insight, and for most of the film I felt as if I were looking at the molted shells of creatures who'd grown and moved on to some other film.
In fairness, the performances are uniformly excellent. Stapleton is a live wire, yet he may be the least unsettling person in the Cody household. Both Ford and Mendelsohn are quieter and more reserved on-screen, but they hide an intensity that could obliterate Darren, the middle child who has to act out to get noticed against the elder and the youngest sons. Mendelsohn, with his weak chin and unassuming physique, may not look like a dealer and a robber, but one shot of his eyes tells you all you need to know about the killer inside. Even Frecheville, stunted as he is in the restrictive part of J, holds his own with the other actors; later in the film, he manages to hold his own against Guy Pearce, who plays a detective who wants to save J from his life but also exploit him to bring down the family.
Pearce's involvement and the tug-of-war between his detective and J, who would just like to go back to the surrogate family he makes with his girlfriend, livens the film. With J poised to sell out his family to be rid of them, Michôd finally unleashes Weaver in all her power, and the results are transcendent. Already the focal point of attention with her subdued presence, Weaver's Janine morphs into a grandmotherly version of Lady Macbeth as police pressure constricts her sons. Her ability to mix open scheming, matronly charm and a veneer of false helplessness makes her the most terrifying character in the film, and her grim, spectral smile is beastly, as if a lioness baring her teeth when an outside force threatens her cubs.
But the turn comes too late, and Animal Kingdom switches into second gear long after it should have been in fifth. Too many elements never come together, from its cold, detached direction to the equally pedestrian electronic score that serves primarily to demonstrate to the skeptics how great and varied and textured other like scores have been recently (compare the nuance and perfectly timed fluctuations of, say, Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross' Social Network score to the unimaginative hum of Anthony Partos'). Some scenes verge on the embarrassing, as the lazily ironic use of Air Supply's "I'm All Out of Love" following a tragedy or a sort-of gangster version of the "You know how I know you're gay?" segment of Knocked Up that haphazardly occurs right after the audience gets introduced to Pope so we lack the investment in the character to get any laughs out of him. I've heard some say that the film is one of the most honest crime movies in years, but I found it too sterile, more realistic in aesthetic than a movie like GoodFellas but not nearly as real. Animal Kingdom fancies itself a character study, but it never studies its characters, and the individual elements of the film, some of which are exemplary, never coalesce, leaving an awkward, plodding mess.
Tuesday, December 21, 2010
Exit Through the Gift Shop
The question of whether Exit Through the Gift Shop is nothing more than street artist Banksy's double-bluff, as with all such matters, strikes me as one not worth answering, or at least not if it means wracking one's brain in an attempt to look beyond the movie instead of just taking in the actual product. Besides, the answer is obviously "yes", or "yes, but..." Kind-of, sort-of the outgrowth of one man's attempt to document Banksy, among many other street artists, Exit Through the Gift Shop gets flipped on its head, so that the subject becomes the uncredited director and the erstwhile filmmaker becomes the subject.Frankly, that's as it should be. The man at the center of Banksy's film, Thierry Guetta, is such a card that his open-faced innocence and charm beat out Banksy's carefully maintained mystery and iconography. We meet Guetta as a man making it in Los Angeles by buying up vintage clothes for $50 an item and adding a few measly touches to pass them off as "designer" wear for 10, even 1,000, times the cost. It's not that he's evil or greedy, just someone who casually tinkered with a piece of clothing until the trendy came along and threw money at the man (would you say no?). His continuation of this con amounts to a subtle form of pranksterism, something that makes the transition into the next stage of his life more understandable.
On holiday back in France, Guetta reunites with his cousin, who now goes by the name Space Invader and, sure enough, spends his time designing stickers based on the characters from his nom de plume and throwing them on walls, signs and bridges all around Paris. Suddenly, Guetta is exposed to the underground world of street art, and he's hooked.
Always armed with a camera, Guetta documented his boutique in L.A. constantly -- much to the chagrin of nearby celebrities who understandably mistake his innately curious nature for paparazzi-esque -- but he faces even more backlash for trying to film people who could be charged for vandalism. In some of his earliest recorded footage of following around street artists, we can see Guetta's amateur mistakes, especially his penchant for turning on the camera's light to get a better shot, in the process illuminating the heretofore inconspicuous artist.
And yet, Guetta presses on in his filming, and even when the weeks turn into months and years and more of the artists he trails question why he keeps filming, they allow him to keep doing so. Thierry has a strange charisma, a man who is both stupider and far more intelligent than he looks. He is a pathological liar, never doing so out of malice but simply to avoid trouble, and his ability to diffuse tension works equally well with authorities as it does his reluctant subjects.
This first half of the film, focused primarily on Guetta and the thousands of hours of footage he collected over the years, makes for the most revealing work ever made on street art. Guetta is like an art critic in the classic sense, not simply discussing the scene but living it. If the artists -- caught between flattery and trepidation of the increased attention Thierry brings -- could afford to gain full notoriety, he'd probably go the next step and promote them as much as he could. Watching clips of Guetta's gathered tapes, it's impossible to view what these people do as mere graffiti: this is daring, often political and utterly beautiful. The sheer range of expression captured is enormous, from a man who paints the outlines of objects shadows to giant posters with satirical intent being erected on buildings. Had it continued in this vein, Exit Through the Gift Shop might have been one of my favorite films of the year.
Then, Banksy comes into the picture. The most infamous and elusive of London's street artists, Banksy comes to Los Angeles, only to get stuck without his usual guide, who fails to gain entry into the country. Artists recommend Guetta, who had tried and failed to meet Banksy, since he knows where all the taggable walls are. After spending some time with the odd Frenchman, even Banksy is rendered powerless to resist him, and he allows Thierry to come back to London and film him. Banksy's entourage is stunned.
Banksy's emergence slows the film to a crawl, replacing the bouncing nature of Guetta's purposeless but devoted charting of the underground to Banksy's manipulation of him as a complex piece of commentary. Banksy is genuinely impressed by Guetta's knack for avoiding trouble -- Banksy makes a detour to Disneyland where he sets up a dummy of a Guantanamo Bay prisoner on the Big Thunder Mountain Railroad ride, and Guetta gets detained by security but somehow manages to hide film in his socks, alert Banksy that the jig is up, and get released without issue -- but he also realizes that the film the Frenchman claims to be making will be a load of crap.
When Banksy's L.A. exhibition causes a sensation and capitalizes the movement, he starts molding Guetta into a street artist in his own right. It is Guetta who comes up with his new persona, Mr. Brainwash, and Guetta who shrewdly sets the hype machine spinning until all of Los Angeles cannot stop talking about this new artist, but it is Banksy who knows the ultimate goal. Clearly, Mr. Brainwash's rise to succès signifies the changing nature of street art and how quickly the mainstream is adopting it, but so what?
The film, like Banksy's art, is provocative and smart but also carries the feeling of being incomplete, as if the final punchline will always be in the next painting. In his talking head, Banksy silhouettes himself and masks his voice, and you get the idea that he does this not to hide from cops but his fans who undermine his committed but naïve views on the purity of his art. As he spends the entire second half ensuring he extends that mystery, he winds up stretching himself too thin. By standing back and letting Guetta have his moment, he proves how easy it is to create a stir in the increasingly gossipy art world, but at the end of the day, he's still a commodity.
I'm torn on the film. It's second half is nothing but the lead up to a joke, but that joke kills: watching yuppies line up in excitement to buy something a magazine told them was cool sight unseen is hysterical, and their pretentious opinions on the art being exhibited had me in tears. But the loss of momentum and the sudden feeling of pointlessness that set in distracted me from what had been fascination with the movie's look into street art culture. I came away from Exit Through the Gift Shop with a renewed interest in the practice of urban art, but I was also frustrated by Banksy constantly undercutting his own gag. Having just watched the documentary on Joan Rivers, I was struck by how seriously she took comedy as she meticulously categorized her jokes into file cabinets. But at least she allowed herself a chuckle at the situation. Banksy, performance artist as much as painter, is bound to be the straight man in a solo act. Maybe he saw Guetta as his double, his Costello, but when Thierry's prank swells even beyond the realms of the satire Banksy intended, I got the nagging suspicion that maybe this time, the joke was on him.
Labels:
2010,
Documentary
Joan Rivers: A Piece of Work
It's a shame that my generation's knowledge of Joan Rivers generally extends no further than her involvement with red carpet shows -- "Can we talk?" and "Who are you wearing" ensconced in the public vernacular -- and the endless plastic surgery jokes made at her expense. For anyone willing to even lightly peruse archives of her stand-up will find one of the sharpest minds in the field, a comic so ahead of the curve that she still comes off confrontational long after other Tonight Show favorites like Don Rickles have become parodies of themselves. The distinction between Rickles and Rivers is that everyone else is trying to make a joke out of Joan, but she always hits back the haters with something far wittier.Joan Rivers, A Piece of Work was made by Ricki Stern and Anne Sundberg, who previously directed the Darfur documentary The Devil Came on Horseback and The Trials of Darryl Hunt (about a man falsely imprisoned for 20 years for a rape/murder), and it surprisingly stands in the company of those hard-hitting and bleak looks at the world. Charting a year in the life of the then-75-year-old comedienne, the film spotlights Rivers' state of flux between being a respected icon and being a cast-off in the perpetual motion youth machine that is show business. In the first few minutes, she goes over her schedule and holds up a blank planner, calling it her worst nightmare. For someone who might still seem ubiquitous through all her awards coverage, Rivers struggles to hang on as she works the same nightclubs she performed in before Johnny Carson launched her career.
Unlike some of her contemporaries, Rivers isn't cashing in on nostalgia. She doesn't enjoy showbiz tenure in Vegas, doesn't have a trove of DVDs and CDs to re-release all the time. She agrees to anything that comes her way to keep her in the spotlight. She knows she's selling her soul for Celebrity Apprentice and those awful perversions of old Friar's Club roasts that have turned personal and honorific jokes into a parade of half-talented hacks finding ways to tell the same three jokes. But how else to pay for her opulent lifestyle, or her generosity toward her staff and especially their children? (Reference is made to her putting the kids of her staff through private school, at least a $100,000 investment per child just to get them to the collegiate level.) She and her manager joke about the gaps in her schedule when she isn't jumping at something, anything, but they seem to laugh that they may not cry.
Rivers' comic style has always been candid, and she's nothing if not frank here. On her plastic surgery, she speaks of the industry's hatred of age and the hypocrisy of those same people turning around and mocking her for taking measures to maintain that youth. The tutting and clucking of tongues is the most rank, sexist bullshit you can imagine, and one can plainly see that insulting someone's modified looks hardly helps someone who got the surgery in the first place over insecurity over looks. In old clips of her talk show performances, Joan pokes fun at her appearance, but when the filmmakers return to the present and Rivers casually says in the middle of makeup that no man ever told her she was beautiful, we get a piercing, off-the-cuff insight into the pain that motivates her humor.
For 84 minutes, Rivers takes us into similarly revealing territory. She speaks of the poisoning of her relationship with Carson, destroyed when she parlayed her frequent guest hosting gigs on the Tonight Show into a competing talk program on Fox. That show cost her Johnny, and her husband, driven so mad by executives' manipulation that he committed suicide and left Joan and Melissa with massive debts. We learn she cares more for acting than comedy, having gotten into stand-up to pay the bills while she tried to launch her acting career -- making her perhaps the only person to try stand-up to make money. But once Carson told her she'd be a star, she threw herself into the business, and she shows the directors a wall of file cabinets in her home containing cards with jokes written on them arranged by alphabetized subjects -- "My Sex Life" sits nearby "No Self-Worth." Fearful of the younger comics with their hidden writers, Rivers fills these shelves with cards, a one-woman writing staff cataloging bits as if preparing for the talk show she no longer has.
Though it never dips into Spinal Tap territory, A Piece of Work does offer a stark look at the entertainment industry when a star enters late age. Rivers voices her disdain for hearing she's a legend or that she's opened doors because that's what one says of the dead and retired. She is invited to perform at the Kennedy Center tribute for George Carlin, and she rightly notes that Carlin would have despised the whole thing, and that the Establishment praises him in death as the final insult and dismantling of his power. Flanked by comics who, for the most part, barely knew him, Rivers feels the pain of the event and its meaning more than anyone. But, once again, she goes on anyway, disgusted by the spectacle yet perversely honored that she was considered. If she doesn't go, they'll be doing this same, eulogistic ceremony for her next year and she'll still be alive.
And yet, she soldiers on, still grateful for every fan, still primed for every gig. The Celebrity Apprentice and Comedy Central Roast gambles pay off: Rivers gets back in the spotlight, but she's too much of a professional to wallow in it. She gets more gigs, endless appearances, off them, and suddenly people can still see how fiery she is. Like another examination of dedication in the face of adversity, Anvil! The Story of Anvil, A Piece of Work may be depressing, but it's ultimately uplifting. Through all her hardships, Joan never gives up, and she still has the drive. She's abrasive but unfailingly kind, and if she insulted you on the street, it's only because that's how you rib a friend. Her blend of vulgarity and grandmotherly care can be seen when a Hellen Keller joke inspires the rage of a heckler with a deaf son. She berates him into silence but clearly feels bad, and when other fans come to her after the show for autographs and slam him, she quietly says, "But he does have a deaf son." It's the clearest display of how Rivers has evolved these 40 years in the limelight, both as a performer attempting to stay fresh and as a person who clings to all the family she has left. Throughout the movie, Joan Rivers insists she's not through yet and still has something to say. By the end, you'll realize she doesn't need to keep making the point. She makes it every time she goes on stage.
Labels:
2010,
Anne Sundberg,
Documentary,
Joan Rivers,
Ricki Stern
Monday, December 20, 2010
Mother
Bong Joon-ho's Mother has and will continue to court references to Alfred Hitchcock's Psycho for its depiction of an Oedipal relationship gone mad, but the Koren director deserves comparison to the Master of Suspense for successfully mining Hitch's most overlooked asset as the king of the pre-blockbuster era: his humor. Like Hitchcock's films, Mother is immaculately executed and rooted in psychological thriller structures, but the manner in which it toys with outright farce without losing momentum may be its most impressive feat.The film's first shot encapsulates its combination of unsettling drama and broad comedy. Opening in an establishing shot in a field, Bong's camera captures a woman walking through the tall, dried grass, her blue and purple clothes clashing with the earthen tones around her despite the faded and worn quality of the garments. Wandering closer to the camera, the middle-aged woman stops and looks confused, then she breaks into a slow, awkward dance. Even without context, the moment is tragicomic, the desperation in the actress' (Kim Hye-ja) face mingling with the uncomfortable chuckles elicited from watching a random person dance in such a raw and unexplained fashion.
The unnamed woman is the titular mother to Do-joon, a sweet, mentally disabled young man who spends his days hanging around just across the street from where his mother prepares and sells medicinal herbs. Mostly, though, she just stares at the boy, making sure she keeps track of him and narrowing her eyes when his ne'er-do-well friend, Jin-tae, comes along. As she slices her dried herbs, she grows ever more concerned with Jin-tae and less focused on the blade she's working. Just as Jin-tae starts to take the lad away on some other foolish adventure, a Mercedes Benz strikes Do-joon right as the mother slides her finger too far under the blade. It's a masterfully edited segment that makes you laugh even as you jump from the startle -- you could almost call it shock and guffaw and then send over an exorcist to purge my possessed soul of Gene Shalit's demon.
Do-joon and Jin-tae chase down the hit-and-run driver, finding their way to a golf course where they vandalize the vehicle and hide out on the course waiting for the drivers to come along. When the guilty, upper-middle-class party rolls by on a cart, the boys spring their ambush, but their assault is more childish than anything, tackling the men on the ground and chasing off the wives who attempt to intervene. At the police station, the cops try to settle the matter without charges, canceling out the hit and run and the assault and forcing the lads to pay for the vandalism. The officers' condescending but well-meaning nature toward Do-joon is partially explained when the boy's mother, having heard of the problem, bursts into the station cheerily addressing each of the policemen there by their names and handing them her homemade elixirs. She collects her son and tries to pin all the bad behavior on Jin-tae -- a not entirely unjustified sentiment -- and sets about raising the money to pay the fine.
Everything appears to settle down, until Do-joon goes out drinking one night and the police arrest him the next morning for the murder of a young woman he drunkenly hit on. Suddenly, the police who seemed willing to cut the poor kid some slack now manipulate the dim man into signing a confession that allows them to avoid any expensive investigation. When the mother visits Do-joon in jail, she asks "Why did you do it?" in hysterics, only to reveal that, for her, the "it" in question is sign the confession. The audience might doubt Do-joon's guilt, but the mother won't even consider it. When the cops won't take the measures necessary to do a full forensic investigation, she takes it upon herself to find the evidence to exonerate her son.
Her exploits, as with everything about the film, are humorous, but Bong grounds the absurdity in his elegant direction. My slow introduction to the more popular side of contemporary Asian cinema has been as revelatory as my immersion into its artier side: Bong, like his similar but less satirically honed colleague Park Chan-wook and the Hong Kong maestro Johnnie To, has a keen ability for striking a balance between comedy and dramatic suspense without letting one win out. There's no winking aside to the audience, no cheap indication of what we should laugh at and what we should take seriously. Bong can drop a joke in the middle of a vital scene, giving a lighter boost to the severity while also undercutting the laugh.
Bong's color scheme, especially in the family's home, is blue and distant. The characters live in a city small enough to be a place where everyone knows each other but large enough that no one cares about this. The mother stamps all over the place hunting for clues, willing to incriminate anyone to protect her son and finding people equally willing to let him take the fall even if they themselves are not the ones who murdered the girl.
A creepy chill hangs over the relationship between mother and child, what the Bates clan might have looked like before the mother died and drove poor Norman mad with grief. The mother feeds Do-joon broth as he pees against a wall, and the boy sleeps in his mom's bed, curling up against her and even tangling his legs with hers. As the boy sits in his cell, the mother comes undone from the separation, reacting more frantically than the overprotected boy. An extreme long shot looks down on a ridged graveyard as the mother moves through it, and when Bong cuts to a grieving family at a ceremony there, he gives us just enough space for the horror of recognition to set in before the old woman bursts in and tells the family of the murdered girl that her son is innocent.
As the mother's sanity frays from the pressure, Bong's framing emphasizes the madness without dipping into full surrealism. The whodunit aspects are done with instant time jumps as each person the mother corners a new subject and demands their story, and the instantaneous movement through time recalls Edgar Wright's ingenious circumventing of segues. Bong never has to resort to any major aesthetic shifts to communicate the building madness, rightly judging that Kim's perfectly paced descent into insanity is sufficient to get the point across. She does not walk around the outskirts of town but march through them, her determined face and wild eyes shrinking the mountains and fields around her. Kim is so good that she makes the normal surreal, turning reality into something inadequate to contain her. So desperate is she to exercise her maternal care once more that when Jin-tae, whom she attempted to frame for the murder, hides in the house to confront her when she returns home, the woman offers food to the furious boy before he says anything.
Mother's revelations about the double-edged sword of all-consuming love complicate the film's central relationship and only drive the mother further around the bend. By the time the plot is concluded -- let us not say "resolved" -- the actions she has taken, coupled with her blindness to facts she picked up along her manic investigation, have fractured the woman beyond repair. But Bong's camera remains steady, detached and graceful, objective even in the heights of its subjective fantasy. It is a remarkable achievement, propelling one of the finer films to come ashore in the States this year even higher. I have read some reviews that praise the film's structure, acting and direction to the heavens, only to pull back and say something along the lines of "but it's still just a conventional thriller." Well, obviously it isn't if everything about the film is immaculately executed. Mother may not offer great new insights into the human condition or the oft-mined realm of warped maternal relationships, but it does find a new route to the same destination. Sometimes, that's all you need.
Labels:
2010,
Bong Joon-ho,
Kim Hye-ja
Sunday, December 19, 2010
Steven Spielberg: Hook
The story of Hook's inspiration is, like the film itself, at once so brilliantly and frustratingly childlike that everything that works and fails can be gleaned from its conception. Nick Castle, originally slated to direct a Peter Pan movie after Spielberg gave up the idea, got the idea from his son. The boy did something that only a child ever has the gall to do: when presented with an absolute -- Peter Pan never grows up -- he questioned why. That twist made it perfect for Spielberg to take over the project; only a Disney-fed eternal child like him would think to continue pursuing that idea, and only Spielberg could use it as the last major expulsion of his pet themes before he entered the more serious phase of his career.Originally slated to make a version of the original Peter Pan in the '80s, Spielberg shelved the project when he had his first child. Wisely, he also believed his thoughts on childhood and the perversion of either staying young in a harshly adult world or maturing too quickly were thoroughly expounded with Empire of the Sun. For Hook, he approaches the same topic from the opposite angle: now that he's a father, a father who might be gone months of the year on location shooting, Spielberg clearly fears he might become the same absentee father that he endured as a child. Thus, for all the light, occasionally distracting comedy of the tale, Hook has as much to say about the director's hangups as any of his other films.
Ingeniously, he recasts Peter Pan as Peter Banning, a Baby Boomer lawyer who, as Wendy (yes, that Wendy) rightly notes, has become a modern pirate. Opening with a Truffaut homage in the form of children's upturned faces as they watch their peers perform a school play of Peter Pan, Hook's gentle mood is broken ever so slightly the second it settles upon Peter (Robin Williams) as he watches his daughter on the stage playing Wendy. Then, it shatters when he cell phone rings. Ignoring his daughter, he then makes plans that conflict with his son Jack's baseball game in the morning.
Though the film tracks Peter, Spielberg roots it in a child's perspective, preparing for the eventual shift back to Neverland but also allowing everyone but Peter to see the effects of his behavior. It is a shame that Spielberg never gives us the point of view of Peter's adult self, the desire to work hard and provide comfortable lives for his family, but then that point of view has always reeked of self-justification anyway and the misery of his family hardly speaks to their well-being.
Only when the family heads to London with a still-fuming Jack does Peter's humanity show. There to help Granny Wendy (Maggie Smith, who in her younger days played Peter on the stage) with a hospital wing dedication in her honor, Peter is still distracted. At the actual dinner, however, he shines, beautifully paying tribute to the woman who took in him and other orphans without saying much at all. Contrasted with his previous coldness, and an ill-timed shift in the deal he thought was a lock causes him to explode at his children, we can see the good man in Peter, even if he cannot.
The lighting in this first segment is soft, tranquil but also ghostly. This is most visible at the charity ball where dozens of table lamps first illuminate the power and meaning of Wendy's efforts with orphans then turn cold and ominous as Hook's return sends waves of chilled atmosphere rolling across an already frigid London. Once Peter is lured back to Neverland -- by, who else, that zipping ball of light known as Tinker Bell (Julia Roberts) -- Spielberg alters the lighting scheme to something brighter, more optimistic, replacing artificial light with the natural sunlight the office-bound Peter likely had not noticed in years.
Spielberg has his fun with the character, making Peter Pan not only a grown man but one with an intense fear of heights and flying. After stumbling into Hook's pirate hangout and confronting the mad captain, Peter must suffer the humiliation of having to chase his trapped children up a mast under the ultimatum that, if he can simply fly like Pan and touch Jack and Maggie's hands, they can go free. All the poor man can do is tremble and fail when he attempts to climb out and grab them. Only Tinker Bell's quick-thinking saves the Bannings from death, and her successful plying of Hook's vanity gives Peter a shot at rediscovering his past self to add some punch to the fight.
Without question, Hook is a flawed film. Nowhere are the issues more apparent than in the Lost Boys' hideaway, a bizarre yet unimaginative mash-up of classical tree house structure with modern touches like a skate park(!). The use of oddly placed bright paint -- contained in suction-cup arrows, placed in a large pool used for rough landings in flying lessons -- captures less a sense of the childhood id gone mad than Spielberg grasping at straws for something that might amuse a kid. For a director all too often accused of being emotionally stunted, Spielberg suffers from the opposite problem here: like Peter, he's grown up, and returning to his innocence proves an unexpected challenge.
The most egregious indicator of the director's age showing is the dinner scene, where Peter looks on helplessly as the Lost Boys eat what appears to be nothing until he too plays along and finds a feast laid before him. As the dinner begins and the children exclaim over the foods they're eating, one boy exultantly shouts "banana squash!" What goddamn child in the history of human existence has ever lost his mind for banana squash? Adults don't even get excited for it. You're telling me that a child (a runaway child with no parental conditioning, no less), left to imagine his ultimate meal, would A) have anything that could even pass as a vegetable and B) wouldn't invent some magical meat made of ice cream? It's a small detail, I grant you, but it's indicative of the issues that mar the film.
Likewise, the Lost Boys themselves lack characterization beyond their appearance, from the jovial, roly-poly Thud Butt to a wee lad whose shortness reveals an impish cad. I've been watching this film since before I could even remember, and I've yet to decide whether Rufio works as a character or derails the entire picture. That a Lost Boy would assume authority of the troupe in Pan's absence is sensible, but there are several problems with Rufio. For one thing, even though Pan was always the biggest of the Lost Boys, he hovered around 12 and 13. Rudio looks like he drove into Neverland after stealing his stepdad's GTO and avoiding the prom because his high school suspended him. For another, he does not ever fit in with the other boys, and his attempts to engage in the goofy imagination that occupies the Lost Boys' time resemble a teen awkwardly breaking out old toys and messing with them like an Alzheimer's patient who has forgotten their function.
By the same token, he obviously looks like the clear leader in Peter's absence, and his half-punk styling fits within the genteel vision of Lord of the Flies that is the adolescent anarchy of the Lost Boys. He regards Peter with scorn because he's a grown-up, but the more Peter proves himself and reveals his inner Pan, the more Rufio prepares to hand power back without a fight. Dante Basco clearly had fun working on this large-scale production, an undeniable step up from his start as a child breakdancer and bit actor, and the twinkle in his eye as he gets to sneer at Robin Williams carries the character much further than anything he actually says.
What the film does well is explore Peter's half-regression, half-evolution to a man who remembers his responsibilities but also taps into his childish side. Williams finds one of his best mixes of his manic, often grating comic style and powerful but occasionally maudlin dramatic side, and he arguably wouldn't better the balance he found here until World's Greatest Dad last year. He plays Peter as the sort of man who would yell, "When are you going to stop acting like a child?" at his 10-year-old son, who has the only possible answer: "I am a child!" In Neverland, Williams has the unlikely role of straight man, the one who has to remain calm and incredulous instead of unleashing his series of impersonations and stream-of-consciousness rants. Fresh off two lauded dramatic performances in Dead Poets Society and Awakenings that showed off his Julliard-honed skills, Williams perhaps uses Peter's arc to get back in touch with his own roots.
Still, even when the old, playful Pan reemerges, the best comedy of the film by a mile belongs to the double act of Hook and Smee. Hoffman and Bob Hoskins could not be more game for their roles, and they play their relationship less as master and servant than mental patient and caretaker, Smee constantly trying to buck up Hook in his incessant and hysterical bouts with suicidal depression. Hoffman takes the same tics and obsessive mannerisms that made Rain Man so borderline offensive and turns them into comedy gold: his Hook is all slight nods and twitching lips, trying vainly to act respectable until he explodes in villainous glee. There's a reason the film is called Hook, because whenever he's on-screen, the film swells.
Symbols of emotional and physical baggage run through Spielberg's films, from suitcase a starved, half-mad Jamie drags out of the internment camp in Empire of the Sun to the image of the Devil's Tower Roy cannot get out of his mind until he leaves it, and Earth (and his family), behind him in Close Encounters of the Third Kind. Several predominant symbols in Hook lock and unlock memories, their potency enhanced by Neverland's ability to make one forget himself. Before leaving for the charity function, Peter attempts to make amends with Jack by giving him his watch, a sign of adulthood and responsibility. Hook, naturally, hates clocks of all kinds owing to that damn crocodile that haunts him even after he killed it, uses that watch to break Jack. Playing on the boy's resentment of his father, Hook brainwashes Jack into loving him instead, and the clear break comes when the boy smashes Peter's watch.
Another symbol is a baseball, which Jack carries around with him. Hook organizes a baseball game to fully win Jack over, and when the boy hits the home run he never could in the real world, he finally gets his perfect childhood wish even as he sends the symbol of his innocence rocketing away from him. When it hits Peter on the head, it helps jog back his own priorities, but he must find his own repository of childhood to fully reawaken his own powers. This he finds in a teddy bear, a symbol Spielberg already used way back in his first theatrical feature, The Sugarland Express, thus tying Peter's childhood with his own.
These intelligent touches keep me coming back to Hook long after I should have grown out of it, but they remain frustrating when taken with the film's many missteps. There's a terrific moment of slapstick during the pirates' ballgame when a man tries to steal second and is shot, much to Hook's annoyance, but the funniness of the moment also begs the question why Jack just doesn't react at all to a man being murdered in front of him, in some ways because of him and his desire to play a game no one else in Neverland understands. The climactic fight should carry the weight of two old rivals engaging in their final duel, but the slapstick of the Lost Boys' involvement turns a bloodbath into Home Alone; I half-expected Commander Macaulay Culkin to lead a division of Lost Boys. And in one of the film's true serious moments, Peter's recollection of his mother and how he came to Neverland, Spielberg and his writers come up with a backstory that clashes with the director's visual accompaniment. Peter speaks of fleeing his family because he was afraid of mortality, yet the film shows his baby carriage simply sliding away (and his mother just not reacting in any way whatsoever). Even setting that aside on grounds of whimsy and fantasy, we're still left with a baby who was apparently engaged in philosophical rumination on the nature of death, and suddenly we're back in banana squash territory.
Yet I still do enjoy Hook, with its Hook/Smee dynamic (further proof that Spielberg can make comedy work when he adheres to a more classical structure instead of his more epically scaled missteps) and the form that only Spielberg can bring. He breaks from reality as soon as possible here, casting an intense but cold light reminiscent of the the passing UFOs in Close Encounters of the Third Kind outside the children's bedroom in Wendy's house. Shots bookend each other, whether in close proximity -- a long shot of Peter standing on the balcony after the children's abduction to Tinker Bell flying in and assuming a similar scale with the dollhouse inside. Spielberg had no reason to go to Neverland, not after saying everything he could have said there in an internment camp in Shanghai, but he does find new topics for discussion even if they might have been better served elsewhere. At its core, Hook is one of two expulsions of Spielberg's "old" style before he entered into the modern phase of his career. Unlike Empire of the Sun, both Hook and Jurassic Park would couch his themes in his more broadly entertaining élan. But if Hook is all about taking out all the childish things we put away, the director used it to stow his old self as he prepared for one of the most remarkable late-careers of any prominent filmmaker.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)